Returning graduates miss out on top jobs
Going home after graduating means you're more likely to wind up in non-graduate jobs, new study finds
Graduates who leave their hometown to study but return for work are more likely to be in lower-paid non-graduate roles six months after leaving university, reports Prospects.
The spring edition of Prospects’ Graduate Market Trends (GMT) recently analysed Higher Education Statistics Agency data to identify four graduate migration patterns and their impact on employability six months after graduation.
A quarter of the graduate workforce was ‘Regional Returners’ – those who leave home to study but return for work. Particularly dominant in the East of England and more likely to use personal contacts instead of university careers services to find work, 40% were working in secretarial, retail and other non-professional roles.
Conversely, the most mobile group, ‘Regional Incomers’ – graduates who moved away from home and their place of study to work – accounted for 18% of the graduate workforce and were least likely to be in a non-graduate job (16%). 44% were working in London.
‘Incomers’ were more likely to be from backgrounds of greater participation in higher education and to state that they had exactly the job they wanted. Those who were in non-graduate employment were more likely to be in office work than other graduates.
Nearly half (45%) of the graduate workforce worked and studied in their home region. These ‘Regional Loyals’ were more likely to be from a background with lower participation in higher education and to work in health or education. A fifth had gone back to a previous employer of some kind after graduation. ‘Loyals’ made up over half of the graduate workforce in Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and the North East and North West of England.
12% of graduates travelled away to study, but remained near their university to work. ‘Stayers’ were the most likely group to have used their careers services to find work and to be in the arts or media. They were the least likely to use traditional media to find work. ‘Stayers’ were most likely to be working in Yorkshire and Humberside (20%).
The analysis was undertaken by Charlie Ball, head of higher education intelligence at Prospects, who said: “Graduates aren’t as mobile as is sometimes believed and we need to recognise that in many parts of the country, the graduate labour market will be dominated by people with a prior connection to the area, either as previous residents or students.
“A significant group go home after university as they’re unable to secure work and consequently find themselves in less satisfactory careers. On the other hand we see that people from more affluent backgrounds seem to be more likely to move around in search of better-paid jobs, particularly in finance and technology, and this has implications for the social mobility agenda.
Universities need to do their best to ensure that graduates who have settled locally are accessing advice and support so that if they do return home, they get help in finding better jobs locally – Charlie Ball, head of higher education intelligence
“Universities need to do their best to ensure that graduates who have settled locally are accessing advice and support so that if they do return home, they get help in finding better jobs locally – particularly with small businesses.
“More institutions need to open their doors to graduates who weren’t their alumni. We should agree a national support system, so graduates can get careers advice wherever they end up.”
Prospects GMT can be downloaded at www.hecsu.ac.uk.